6UL wheels still cracking...
#2
Newsflash: wheels used regularly on track will crack. You should regularly inspect your track wheels, and 6ULs are not unique in this regard. Early 6ULs were more prone to this, but later generations have been performing within expected parameters.
EDIT: Since the OP couldn't be bothered to link anything, here is the m.net thread:
https://forum.miata.net/vb/showthread.php?t=701617
Owner has a legit gripe IMO, wheels should last through several sets of tires barring abuse. Important to note that these are the 17" wheels, not the 15" wheels that had the issues 7 years ago. As far as I'm aware 3rd and 4th gen 15" wheels have been lasting as long as would be expected. Looks like there may need to be some changes to the 17" wheels.
EDIT: Since the OP couldn't be bothered to link anything, here is the m.net thread:
https://forum.miata.net/vb/showthread.php?t=701617
Owner has a legit gripe IMO, wheels should last through several sets of tires barring abuse. Important to note that these are the 17" wheels, not the 15" wheels that had the issues 7 years ago. As far as I'm aware 3rd and 4th gen 15" wheels have been lasting as long as would be expected. Looks like there may need to be some changes to the 17" wheels.
Last edited by dleavitt; 09-08-2019 at 12:02 PM.
#4
"Wheels are a wear item" bla bla bla
My experience, and that of many I know, is that other wheels last much longer than 6ULs. My second gen 6UL's made it through about 10 HPDE track days - with no curb impacts, running street tires - before cracking. I was told to pound sand when I voiced my concern, like pretty much everyone else. 949 may make some good stuff, and I'm glad for their contribution to the community, but I stay away from 6ULs because I cant afford to replace them every season and their service if something breaks is awful. The only reason I felt comfortable buying XIDAS was because they're made by Tractive.
Totally unscientific as well, but put "miata wheels cracked 6ul" in google and see how many more people have issues with this wheel than anything else - TRM, Advanti storm, etc. have almost nothing, while there are pages of people with cracked 6UL's. One recent thread suggests a serious design flaw in the current 17x9 6UL, as 3 separate customers in that thread alone had 3-4 of their wheels cracking in the same spot.
My experience, and that of many I know, is that other wheels last much longer than 6ULs. My second gen 6UL's made it through about 10 HPDE track days - with no curb impacts, running street tires - before cracking. I was told to pound sand when I voiced my concern, like pretty much everyone else. 949 may make some good stuff, and I'm glad for their contribution to the community, but I stay away from 6ULs because I cant afford to replace them every season and their service if something breaks is awful. The only reason I felt comfortable buying XIDAS was because they're made by Tractive.
Totally unscientific as well, but put "miata wheels cracked 6ul" in google and see how many more people have issues with this wheel than anything else - TRM, Advanti storm, etc. have almost nothing, while there are pages of people with cracked 6UL's. One recent thread suggests a serious design flaw in the current 17x9 6UL, as 3 separate customers in that thread alone had 3-4 of their wheels cracking in the same spot.
Last edited by Morello; 09-07-2019 at 10:13 PM.
#10
There's really only two possibilities, either it's a design flaw or it's a manufacturing (metallurgical) issue. Either way, 949 is liable.
#18
I'm not aware of all the sizes involved. There is a thread on miata.net. Seems it involves at least two wheel sizes that are different product lines. Here's what I've noticed, the wheels all crack in approximately the same area. This suggests to me that it could be a design issue. Questions that need to be answered is who designed the wheels and what were the design specs? The next question is whether the manufacturer is actually producing them to the material specs.