I know Xidas are king, but what if you just want a slight improvement over stock?
#41
While admittedly not up to date on all the options my go to shock for performance daily driver has always been the Bilstein. The big question for the Miata will be how well off the shelf billys perform with your spring rates.
I understand and agree with not going overboard on a cheap daily driver. While difficult to reconcile on paper you'd be hard pressed to find another area of improvement that would have as great of an impact on your enjoyment of the car. Food for thought as you take the plunge.
I understand and agree with not going overboard on a cheap daily driver. While difficult to reconcile on paper you'd be hard pressed to find another area of improvement that would have as great of an impact on your enjoyment of the car. Food for thought as you take the plunge.
#42
Buy cheap, buy twice. That said, if you are going to buy cheap- NB Bilsteins (NOT the NA ones, which have completely different valving), Flyin Miata springs, NB top hats, FCM bump stops. This setup was 85% as good as my Xida GS setup for street driving, and not too shabby on the track. That said, the GS setup was definitely worth the money.
#43
Broke bitch Burger King burger flipper happy meal: Budget bilsteins with 550/350 springs or 450/300 springs.
Home Depot assistant paint department manager flexin': Goodwin Feal 441s
I'm a real boy now and i don't need to have unique brain function slapping meat on table: Xidas in a flavor of your choice
Home Depot assistant paint department manager flexin': Goodwin Feal 441s
I'm a real boy now and i don't need to have unique brain function slapping meat on table: Xidas in a flavor of your choice
The new-to-me NC has MCS DA remotes.
#47
Buy cheap, buy twice. That said, if you are going to buy cheap- NB Bilsteins (NOT the NA ones, which have completely different valving), Flyin Miata springs, NB top hats, FCM bump stops. This setup was 85% as good as my Xida GS setup for street driving, and not too shabby on the track. That said, the GS setup was definitely worth the money.
#49
I've had just about every shock except Fox on my car. I vote either cheap Bilsteins, Xida GS or Xida Race. Pick what fits your budget and goals. The other choices are just not as good, and I loath doing things more than once now. On my GT86, I went with MCS...they are good but I wish there were Xidas available when I purchased.
I just ask because for the average driver, the few % difference between a XIDA or a triple-adjustable Penske.........most aren't going to be able to discern the difference.
#50
I'm curious what you think XIDA specific shocks for the Twins would do better than your MCS setup? Price? Is damping at the front or rear not what you expected, is the spring rate where it needs to be, tires performing as they should as far as temperatures and stuff? Honestly asking out of curiosity, not trying to be a jerk or play a gotcha.
I just ask because for the average driver, the few % difference between a XIDA or a triple-adjustable Penske.........most aren't going to be able to discern the difference.
I just ask because for the average driver, the few % difference between a XIDA or a triple-adjustable Penske.........most aren't going to be able to discern the difference.
The 86 platform is a lot like the Miata and the rear shocks are really short even from the factory. The MCS application for the GT86 was developed in large part by Vorshlag. They opted to split the shocks into two versions, a shorter model for the low boi autocross crowd and another that was stock class compatible. I went with the shorter shock and it is hard to get a reasonable ride height out of them. I am running it a little more than 1" lower than stock (13.5" from the hub to fender) and the car struggles getting in and out of driveways everywhere. It's bad enough I do not take the car places if I know the driveways are troublesome.
This is a photo of the car as it sits today. Raise the car too much and it is going to be outside the sweet spot of bump/droop with the shock length. 949 are the only people I know of that fret over every little detail when it comes to suspension and want to make their product as good as possible, I can't say the same for everyone else out there. From what I've seen them share on the forums about the GT86 Xida, they will have more bump travel front and rear which is a good thing and you can run the car at a reasonable ride height. Additionally, the geometry in the front of this car goes really wonky if you go too low. So it makes the ride height you run that much more important.
Here are a few notes comparing the stock shocks to the MCS. I didn't take measurements of my AST5100s before I sold them but I do have a photo comparing the rear shocks.
Stock struts/shocks with TRD bump stops (shorter than OEM and intended for TRD lowering springs)
Front Strut
148mm total travel
97mm travel with bump stop
51mm bump stop length
Rear Shock
124mm total travel
90mm travel with bump stop
34mm bump stop length
MCS Struts/Shocks (you do not run bump stops)
Front Travel - 108mm
Rear Travel - 102mm
AST5100 rear shock with stock top hat next to MCS short rear shock with Vorshlag coaxial top hat.
Camber plates are a big expense and add a serious amount of NVH to the platform. NVH wise, it's really noticeable on the freeway with grooved concrete sections. It isn't the end of the world, but the car is otherwise a really nice place to be and if I could get rid of the NVH I would but I need the cambers for autocross. I also spent a lot of money on Vorshlag's camber plates and rear top hats with my shocks and they left a lot to be desired. The press fit radial bearings in the spring perches all had different measurements varying 1-5mm in height. Is that a big deal? Probably not but given how much I spent, I was expecting precision not good enough.
I'm mostly salty about their response on that subject and how it was handled. Another issue is camber plates on this platform are all over the place. Every company has a different stack height and most eat into your precious bump travel in the front. My notes show that Vorshlag is one of the better choices when it comes to stack height. Another great design element, /s, of the rear top hats is the top of the shocks contact the inside of the upper spring perch at max travel. They machined those too thick so I run a really slim packard in there to prevent metal on metal contact.
Another challenge with the GT86 suspension design is swaybar endlink interference at race negative camber. Both the AST and MCS have endlink contact at the bottom of the strut if you want more than -3* of camber. The MCS can't even utilize the slotted upper strut bolt without everything contacting. With my Vorshlag camber plates I have a max of ~ -3.3 camber and it still isn't enough even with a less sticky tire like the NT-01. On a RE-71r or A052 at autocross I'm guessing it wants north of -4*. In short, there are a lot of little details that add up to something that I would like a solution for. I see that in the Xida for the GT86 and appreciate the time spent on development to get them right. I would rather throw money at a product than spending my own time doing that.
To answer your last question, I think the average driver would notice a difference between those shocks and they would have a worse time on the 3-way Penskes compared to the Xida. The more adjustments you can make, the more rope you have to hang yourself. Most folks can't even describe handling problems accurately let alone understand what changes need to be made to compensate. Hell, adjusting a 1-way coilover is more adjustment than most want to make. Less is more until you can drive the wheels off what you have but having a good shock under you sure as heck makes it easier to learn what to do.
Last edited by Lincoln Logs; 05-01-2020 at 10:20 AM.
#51
The easy button none of us want to admit to is the ~400/260lb FM Vmaxx Xtreme. You get an application specific fixed length shock, properly configured spring stroke with helpers and even adjustable damping. You can get them with the higher rate ~500/340 Track Pack springs if desired.
I've built myself two sets of diy billies and my new daily came with a set already installed. They need quite a bit more secret saucing than the MT hivemind will admit, hence the 900 page thread. Extended hats, upper spring perches, particular lower perches or custom machined grooves, etc, and then they are only 'happy' up to about 500lb in the front, IMO. The sweet spot is lower than that for street ride quality.
My current set has extended mounts f&r with 'just' 500/350 and my 900/500 Gen2 Xida Race ride significantly better.
I've built myself two sets of diy billies and my new daily came with a set already installed. They need quite a bit more secret saucing than the MT hivemind will admit, hence the 900 page thread. Extended hats, upper spring perches, particular lower perches or custom machined grooves, etc, and then they are only 'happy' up to about 500lb in the front, IMO. The sweet spot is lower than that for street ride quality.
My current set has extended mounts f&r with 'just' 500/350 and my 900/500 Gen2 Xida Race ride significantly better.
#52
Elite Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: Jacksonville, FL
Posts: 1,552
Total Cats: 196
Vmaxxxx is garbage, I had them. Ride like crap on the street and not much better on the track.
My bc coilovers are not top of the line buy most standards here, but they blow vmaxxx away. Much more composed ride and well valved.
Its impossiimpoto buy suspension by looking at a spec sheet and features. Only way is to try for yourself or rely on other people's experiences.
My bc coilovers are not top of the line buy most standards here, but they blow vmaxxx away. Much more composed ride and well valved.
Its impossiimpoto buy suspension by looking at a spec sheet and features. Only way is to try for yourself or rely on other people's experiences.
#54
The easy button none of us want to admit to is the ~400/260lb FM Vmaxx Xtreme. You get an application specific fixed length shock, properly configured spring stroke with helpers and even adjustable damping. You can get them with the higher rate ~500/340 Track Pack springs if desired.
Last edited by Lincoln Logs; 04-30-2020 at 06:27 PM.
#55
Vmaxx xxtreme NA/NB
https://www.topmiata.com/product/v-m...rs-kit-for-na/
$569 shipped from China
Or direct from Netherlands https://www.v-maxx.com/en/products/c...r-kits/2306906
similar shock as FM xxtreme but different spring rates, valving and a few other details. 2.5" so you could always scrounge ebay for alternates.
Also the FM end link it appears https://www.v-maxx.com/en/accessorie...r-1-kit-1-axle
Front
4" x 112# (2kg)
5.5" x 392# (7kg)
Rear
4" x 112# (2kg)
6.7" x 336# (6kg)
https://www.topmiata.com/product/v-m...rs-kit-for-na/
$569 shipped from China
Or direct from Netherlands https://www.v-maxx.com/en/products/c...r-kits/2306906
similar shock as FM xxtreme but different spring rates, valving and a few other details. 2.5" so you could always scrounge ebay for alternates.
Also the FM end link it appears https://www.v-maxx.com/en/accessorie...r-1-kit-1-axle
Front
4" x 112# (2kg)
5.5" x 392# (7kg)
Rear
4" x 112# (2kg)
6.7" x 336# (6kg)
__________________
Last edited by emilio700; 04-30-2020 at 06:48 PM.
#57
Vmaxx xxtreme NA/NB
https://www.topmiata.com/product/v-m...rs-kit-for-na/
$569 shipped from China
Or direct from Netherlands https://www.v-maxx.com/en/products/c...r-kits/2306906
similar shock as FM xxtreme but different spring rates, valving and a few other details. 2.5" so you could always scrounge ebay for alternates.
Also the FM end link it appears https://www.v-maxx.com/en/accessorie...r-1-kit-1-axle
Front
4" x 112# (2kg)
5.5" x 392# (7kg)
Rear
4" x 112# (2kg)
6.7" x 336# (6kg)
https://www.topmiata.com/product/v-m...rs-kit-for-na/
$569 shipped from China
Or direct from Netherlands https://www.v-maxx.com/en/products/c...r-kits/2306906
similar shock as FM xxtreme but different spring rates, valving and a few other details. 2.5" so you could always scrounge ebay for alternates.
Also the FM end link it appears https://www.v-maxx.com/en/accessorie...r-1-kit-1-axle
Front
4" x 112# (2kg)
5.5" x 392# (7kg)
Rear
4" x 112# (2kg)
6.7" x 336# (6kg)
Looks a lot like Tecnas with red springs.