Would you buy a $250 FFS?
#1
Would you buy a $250 FFS?
Hey guys. I've been researching the FFS kit for quite some time, both here and other places. It seems to me that the consensus is that it's a great kit mehanically, but electronically (engine management) not so much. Well, the EMS is decent for 190-200 hp, anyways. Regardless, is it worth the approaching $5,000 price tag? Hell no.
However, I have the opportunity to buy a kit for $250. What's wrong with it, you may ask? Well, it caught fire. LOL
Now, I understand they have a lifetime warranty and Tom has a good reputation for customer support. So assuming we can salvage the kit, and this Tom guy really does back up his warranty (to this extent), would you go for it?
Also, I don't live in CA so smog isn't an issue. How much of a deal is it to run it with a MS setup?
However, I have the opportunity to buy a kit for $250. What's wrong with it, you may ask? Well, it caught fire. LOL
Now, I understand they have a lifetime warranty and Tom has a good reputation for customer support. So assuming we can salvage the kit, and this Tom guy really does back up his warranty (to this extent), would you go for it?
Also, I don't live in CA so smog isn't an issue. How much of a deal is it to run it with a MS setup?
#4
Elite Member
iTrader: (21)
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Rochester, NY
Posts: 6,623
Total Cats: 1,277
Probably have to replace the coupler, or at least change the oil. Depending on how hot it got, the bearings could be toast, too. That said, there are companies that will completely rebuild them fairly reasonably. Friend had an MP45 rebuilt, including recoated rotors for less than I paid for my MP62.
For $250, it's worth a shot.
For $250, it's worth a shot.
#5
Boost Pope
iTrader: (8)
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Chicago. (The less-murder part.)
Posts: 33,339
Total Cats: 6,793
As strong as is the opprobrium which I harbor towards Tom, I have to jump on the "go for it" bandwagon for no other reason than because paying $250 for a supercharger which was consumed in a fire and then building a reliable forced-induction system around it is so positively aligned with the MiataTurbo Chakra that I fully expect kittens and rainbows to come out of the tailpipe under boost.
#6
Well technically breaking and fires are all caused by a faulty something, but I'm splitting hairs and I'm not optimistic about the warranty covering fire. Then again I haven't called Tom yet...still waiting on some pics from the owner.
It's good to hear that MS can be run on it. However I'm swapping a rebuilt 1.8 into a 1.6 chassis. Im assuming that regardless of MS or power cards, I'd need the 1.6 electronics yes?
Finally, would you perhaps know of the company that rebuilt that m45?
It's good to hear that MS can be run on it. However I'm swapping a rebuilt 1.8 into a 1.6 chassis. Im assuming that regardless of MS or power cards, I'd need the 1.6 electronics yes?
Finally, would you perhaps know of the company that rebuilt that m45?
#10
Boost Pope
iTrader: (8)
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Chicago. (The less-murder part.)
Posts: 33,339
Total Cats: 6,793
Is this supercharger a hotside (exhaust-side) or coldside (intake-side) configuration?
While it's possible that there may be some exception I don't know about, all of the kits which FFS makes, to my knowledge, are coldsides. In this configuration, the supercharger bolts directly to a custom-made intake manifold.
Intake manifolds are not interchangeable between the 1.6 and 1.8 cars owing to different port-spacing, and likewise are also not interchangeable between the '94-'97 1.8 engines and the '99-'05 engines. So you need to make sure that the supercharger kit matches the engine you're using, or else you're going to have to buy a new intake manifold.
In terms of wiring, it's somewhat easier if you buy an ECU which matches the year of the wiring harness in the car. For a '94-'97 engine, I'd say that it's best to keep the 1.6 harness. If you're going with a '99-'05 engine, then things get a bit trickier and the benefits of using an engine-year ECU increase somewhat, at the cost of greatly increased harness-hacking.
While it's possible that there may be some exception I don't know about, all of the kits which FFS makes, to my knowledge, are coldsides. In this configuration, the supercharger bolts directly to a custom-made intake manifold.
Intake manifolds are not interchangeable between the 1.6 and 1.8 cars owing to different port-spacing, and likewise are also not interchangeable between the '94-'97 1.8 engines and the '99-'05 engines. So you need to make sure that the supercharger kit matches the engine you're using, or else you're going to have to buy a new intake manifold.
Im assuming that regardless of MS or power cards, I'd need the 1.6 electronics yes?
#12
Buy it no matter what, 250 is a steal for that hardware. If you can't use it, sell it for a profit.
I don't think any sane person is going to warranty a product after it was damaged in a fire. Maybe something like a fire-proof safe, but that's the only thing I can really think of where it might be warrantied due to fire damage.
I don't think any sane person is going to warranty a product after it was damaged in a fire. Maybe something like a fire-proof safe, but that's the only thing I can really think of where it might be warrantied due to fire damage.
#13
Moderator
iTrader: (12)
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Tampa, Florida
Posts: 20,884
Total Cats: 3,075
You won't be happy with powercards. Anyone who has actually tried both will laugh at the idea of being happy with powercards.
Get the supercharger, fine. But don't go full retard. At least try to do the important part correctly if you don't want to buy another engine in 6 months or less. Cold side superchargers are stupid, so you need to make extra sure you are fueling and timing it correctly to stay out of For ***** Sake dumbass-land. Don't set yourself up to be another victim of his design.
Get the supercharger, fine. But don't go full retard. At least try to do the important part correctly if you don't want to buy another engine in 6 months or less. Cold side superchargers are stupid, so you need to make extra sure you are fueling and timing it correctly to stay out of For ***** Sake dumbass-land. Don't set yourself up to be another victim of his design.
#15
Very good points. Thank you all. Now, I'm going to be using a 94-97 engine. I've yet to confirm what model engine the FFS was run on since he's out at lunch. But I think it was indeed on the NA 1.8 so the intake manifolds will match. Good tip on that, though. Thanks.
I take it then that no matter what, a MS unit would be best to use. I was leaning towards that anyways. I've been doing everything top quality so far (machine shop working on engine, etc) so I'd hate to use inefficient power cards.
My question now, and it's probably silly, is could I use a 94-97 engine, a 94-97 model FFS, and a 1.6 model MS?
Thanks again for all the help. Oh, and never mind the 210 hp on power cards comment. Meant to say 190. Oops.
I take it then that no matter what, a MS unit would be best to use. I was leaning towards that anyways. I've been doing everything top quality so far (machine shop working on engine, etc) so I'd hate to use inefficient power cards.
My question now, and it's probably silly, is could I use a 94-97 engine, a 94-97 model FFS, and a 1.6 model MS?
Thanks again for all the help. Oh, and never mind the 210 hp on power cards comment. Meant to say 190. Oops.