Oil cooler tech
#421
Retired Mech Design Engr
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Jan 2013
Location: Seneca, SC
Posts: 5,012
Total Cats: 859
My only comment is to say that the mouth opening of the Miata is larger than needed. Thus the ducting does not need to fill the entire thing, only make sure that the air that is pushed into your duct opening all goes through the radiator.
I did re-route, ducting and oil cooler at the same time, so I don't have a feel for which did which, only that my coolant temps are now in check, and the AIT's have not gotten worse. Now if I ever get my oil temp gauge wired, I'll know if I'm over-cooling it.
I did re-route, ducting and oil cooler at the same time, so I don't have a feel for which did which, only that my coolant temps are now in check, and the AIT's have not gotten worse. Now if I ever get my oil temp gauge wired, I'll know if I'm over-cooling it.
#422
You guys actually have that much faith in Miata dipstick readings?
I usually take a few readings and if one of them looks like the oil is between MIN&MAX I pray that it's correct.
Not sure if this is a Mazda thing, my SP23 is hard to read too - never had issues with other manufacturers.
Given how sensitive rotary engines are, you'd think that Mazda of all companies would have idiot-proof, easy-to-read oil dipsticks!
I usually take a few readings and if one of them looks like the oil is between MIN&MAX I pray that it's correct.
Not sure if this is a Mazda thing, my SP23 is hard to read too - never had issues with other manufacturers.
Given how sensitive rotary engines are, you'd think that Mazda of all companies would have idiot-proof, easy-to-read oil dipsticks!
My Miata dipstick follows the amount of oil I add pretty closely, so I'm sure it's close enough. Halfway between min and max with an eye kept on it seems to be the ticket in my case.
#425
Moderator
iTrader: (12)
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Tampa, Florida
Posts: 21,053
Total Cats: 3,128
Depends upon who you ask. I like the additive package and film strength of Shaeffer's offerings but I know there are plenty of boutique oils and new formulas from established players that didn't exist 10 years ago. Brad Penn, Joe Gibbs, Amsoil, Redline, Valvoline, et al have "ideal" race formulas if you just go by the marketing. You really have to look at the data sheet to decide for yourself or you're really just taking somebody's word for it.
#427
If you're actually running the engine oil hot enough to cause serious degradation (>~150*C sustained), then better cooling is required and any boutique oil is just buying a tiny bit more time before BOOM. People spend way too much effort looking for "what is the best." None of us are running a fully billet 1500hp engine; we don't demand that much from our lubrication system. Keep track of pressure and temp and get an analysis to understand how you engine is wearing and will dictate what is best for you: What is the measured viscosity? Is the oil breaking down from heat? Do I need to change it more or less often? What amount of metal and what types are present? FYI our NSX GT3 runs off the shelf Mobil 1 and they change and analyze the engine oil after every session. It's good enough for a $500k race car and will last an entire 24 hours. You don't need some uber exotic oil, but you should start conservative until you understand what your setup requires; then set it and forget it.
Last edited by engineered2win; 12-21-2017 at 06:48 PM.
#430
Rotella T6. It's $22/gallon on sale.
If you're actually running the engine oil hot enough to cause serious degradation (>~150*C sustained), then better cooling is required and any boutique oil is just buying a tiny bit more time before BOOM. People spend way too much effort looking for "what is the best." None of us are running a fully billet 1500hp engine; we don't demand that much from our lubrication system. Keep track of pressure and temp and get an analysis to understand how you engine is wearing and will dictate what is best for you: What is the measured viscosity? Is the oil breaking down from heat? Do I need to change it more or less often? What amount of metal and what types are present? FYI our NSX GT3 runs off the shelf Mobil 1 and they change and analyze the engine oil after every session. It's good enough for a $500k race car and will last an entire 24 hours. You don't need some uber exotic oil, but you should start conservative until you understand what your setup requires; then set it and forget it.
If you're actually running the engine oil hot enough to cause serious degradation (>~150*C sustained), then better cooling is required and any boutique oil is just buying a tiny bit more time before BOOM. People spend way too much effort looking for "what is the best." None of us are running a fully billet 1500hp engine; we don't demand that much from our lubrication system. Keep track of pressure and temp and get an analysis to understand how you engine is wearing and will dictate what is best for you: What is the measured viscosity? Is the oil breaking down from heat? Do I need to change it more or less often? What amount of metal and what types are present? FYI our NSX GT3 runs off the shelf Mobil 1 and they change and analyze the engine oil after every session. It's good enough for a $500k race car and will last an entire 24 hours. You don't need some uber exotic oil, but you should start conservative until you understand what your setup requires; then set it and forget it.
I used my RX-8 as a torture test bed for different oils and utilized Blackstone reports to tell me which brands performed better (which amounts to longer), what weight to use, and at what intervals to change the oil. I found that ANY quality synthetic could withstand the brutal shear forces of a Renesis engine for at least 8 track hours. Three notable performers were Mobil 1 0W40, Pennzoil Platinum 0W40, and Rotella T6 5W40 (old formula), which held their viscosity longer than I was comfortable running them (at least 12 track hours), and provided adequate lubrication to keep wear metals very low. Based on my results, I ran Rotella T6 for a couple of years, due to its low price: $16 for 5 quarts on sale. When I tired of the rotary stench and put a race cat on the car, I switched to Mobil 1, due to its ubiquity.
Having said that, Valvoline Synpower, Quaker State synthetic, and several other popular brands performed very well, and I would not hesitate to run them for up to 8 track hours. We are lucky to live in the amber age of quality synthetic oils with excellent additive packages.
If an oil will stand up to rotary abuse, it will certainly hold up in a BP engine--even with reasonable F/I. Start with a quality oil, change it at a conservative interval, and send a sample for analysis. Adjust your interval from there and don't worry about it.
For example, when I bought my Miata a little over a year ago, I had a spare jug of Valvoline Synpower 5W30 sitting on the shelf in my garage. I poured it in, ran the car for 8 track hours, and sent a sample to Blackstone. Results were perfectly fine. I now run Mobil 1 0W40 just to keep things consistent between the 2 cars.
#432
Car is basically stock w/o oil cooler or "big radiator". Also starting a build on a second car for the same purpose.
SIXSHOOTER. Thanks for your thoughtful response. We do not have ducting and are running the stock radiator. Lost both motors due to rod/bearing failure. One at High Plains and the other at Hallett. Car owner runs various oil brands, generally a 10w40 weight.
SIXSHOOTER. Thanks for your thoughtful response. We do not have ducting and are running the stock radiator. Lost both motors due to rod/bearing failure. One at High Plains and the other at Hallett. Car owner runs various oil brands, generally a 10w40 weight.
#434
Oil heating cooling
So I'm a fan of the Laminova heat exchangers, but the plumbing on my SE (MSM) doesn't really lend itself to using the radiator outlet. Maybe when I put the built engine in, but that is not now.
I am now considering a fan boosted Setrab in the rhs wheel well, in front of the tyre. I don't want to use the foglight hole because brake cooling. Also, I want to be able to modulate the cooling to even out oil temperature.
My thinking is that a cooler with a fan sitting in that space will not cool much (unducted) until the fan comes on, facilitating faster warm up. Fan on, and cooling happens.
I would like to use a pwm controller to modulate the fan according to temperature, to even out the temperature and ease the load on the alternator. I can't see anyone here who has done that - am I wrong?
I can use the ECU to do this, or I can use an external controller (Mocal sell one). Is one better than the other?
Will the ots thermostats do the same job of modulation, or are they on/off switches (so to speak)?
Appreciate any comments
Thanks!
I am now considering a fan boosted Setrab in the rhs wheel well, in front of the tyre. I don't want to use the foglight hole because brake cooling. Also, I want to be able to modulate the cooling to even out oil temperature.
My thinking is that a cooler with a fan sitting in that space will not cool much (unducted) until the fan comes on, facilitating faster warm up. Fan on, and cooling happens.
I would like to use a pwm controller to modulate the fan according to temperature, to even out the temperature and ease the load on the alternator. I can't see anyone here who has done that - am I wrong?
I can use the ECU to do this, or I can use an external controller (Mocal sell one). Is one better than the other?
Will the ots thermostats do the same job of modulation, or are they on/off switches (so to speak)?
Appreciate any comments
Thanks!
#435
So I'm a fan of the Laminova heat exchangers, but the plumbing on my SE (MSM) doesn't really lend itself to using the radiator outlet. Maybe when I put the built engine in, but that is not now.
I am now considering a fan boosted Setrab in the rhs wheel well, in front of the tyre. I don't want to use the foglight hole because brake cooling. Also, I want to be able to modulate the cooling to even out oil temperature.
My thinking is that a cooler with a fan sitting in that space will not cool much (unducted) until the fan comes on, facilitating faster warm up. Fan on, and cooling happens.
I would like to use a pwm controller to modulate the fan according to temperature, to even out the temperature and ease the load on the alternator. I can't see anyone here who has done that - am I wrong?
I can use the ECU to do this, or I can use an external controller (Mocal sell one). Is one better than the other?
I went with the mocal pwm controller for my radiator fan after hearing lots of good results. The only thing is it comes with a shitty push through probe. I ended up getting a plug and tapping it m6x1 i believe for the sensor
Will the ots thermostats do the same job of modulation, or are they on/off switches (so to speak)?
On off so to speak
Appreciate any comments
Thanks!
I am now considering a fan boosted Setrab in the rhs wheel well, in front of the tyre. I don't want to use the foglight hole because brake cooling. Also, I want to be able to modulate the cooling to even out oil temperature.
My thinking is that a cooler with a fan sitting in that space will not cool much (unducted) until the fan comes on, facilitating faster warm up. Fan on, and cooling happens.
I would like to use a pwm controller to modulate the fan according to temperature, to even out the temperature and ease the load on the alternator. I can't see anyone here who has done that - am I wrong?
I can use the ECU to do this, or I can use an external controller (Mocal sell one). Is one better than the other?
I went with the mocal pwm controller for my radiator fan after hearing lots of good results. The only thing is it comes with a shitty push through probe. I ended up getting a plug and tapping it m6x1 i believe for the sensor
Will the ots thermostats do the same job of modulation, or are they on/off switches (so to speak)?
On off so to speak
Appreciate any comments
Thanks!
#436
Former Vendor
Thread Starter
iTrader: (31)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Sunnyvale, CA
Posts: 15,442
Total Cats: 2,104
PWM is totally unnecessary IMO. Oil has a broad range of acceptable temps, so I would just do a simple on/off channel. You'll save a lot of headaches that way (PWM to a fan would require either a fan controller or a solid state relay).
#437
The RPW - Mocal pump controller referred to in my post, for the record. I just noticed that it seems to be grouped under oil pumps, FWTW.
#438
Junior Member
Join Date: Dec 2015
Location: Brisbane, Queensland, Australia
Posts: 222
Total Cats: 72
Oil Cooler - location tested
I had fitted my oil cooler in the front right hand corner, behind the fog light opening. This is the result of relatively light contact with a tyre barrier - I had to replace the guard, but the bumper and headlight are still serviceable. The oil cooler was mounted with aluminium brackets which tore off with the impact, and sent the cooler under the front wheel.
I still won my class for the event I was competing in, and made it to the top 5 street registered cars at the event, but I had to sit out the last two runs as a result of the oil cooler damage. I will be re-thinking my oil cooler location.
I still won my class for the event I was competing in, and made it to the top 5 street registered cars at the event, but I had to sit out the last two runs as a result of the oil cooler damage. I will be re-thinking my oil cooler location.
#439
I had fitted my oil cooler in the front right hand corner, behind the fog light opening. This is the result of relatively light contact with a tyre barrier - I had to replace the guard, but the bumper and headlight are still serviceable. The oil cooler was mounted with aluminium brackets which tore off with the impact, and sent the cooler under the front wheel.
I still won my class for the event I was competing in, and made it to the top 5 street registered cars at the event, but I had to sit out the last two runs as a result of the oil cooler damage. I will be re-thinking my oil cooler location.
I still won my class for the event I was competing in, and made it to the top 5 street registered cars at the event, but I had to sit out the last two runs as a result of the oil cooler damage. I will be re-thinking my oil cooler location.