Unreliable engine starting?
#42
Moderator
iTrader: (12)
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Tampa, Florida
Posts: 21,029
Total Cats: 3,124
For you guys that weren't raised working on cars with distributors, if the car is hard to start and acts like it is kicking backwards against the starter's rotation (which it is), then retard the cranking timing a few degrees and see if that helps. Keep retarding it a few degrees at a time until it cranks on the first try. It sounds like raising the cranking speed threshold is a good idea, too.
The term for this phenomenon is "kicking back" and not hydrolocking. Hydrolocking is what occurs when a liquid (hydro) (oil, water, fuel) is present in the combustion chamber and cannot be compressed thereby preventing the engine from being turned without damage.
Back a few years, kicking back commonly broke arms, shoulders, noses, and numerous other body parts when individuals had to hand crank automobiles. If the spark advance was not properly retarded when hand cranking, it could severely injure or kill you. Policemen were occasionally thrown over the handlebars of their kick-start motorcycles by the same issue.
The term for this phenomenon is "kicking back" and not hydrolocking. Hydrolocking is what occurs when a liquid (hydro) (oil, water, fuel) is present in the combustion chamber and cannot be compressed thereby preventing the engine from being turned without damage.
Back a few years, kicking back commonly broke arms, shoulders, noses, and numerous other body parts when individuals had to hand crank automobiles. If the spark advance was not properly retarded when hand cranking, it could severely injure or kill you. Policemen were occasionally thrown over the handlebars of their kick-start motorcycles by the same issue.
#44
The car starts and runs just fine 90% of the time. So no, spark outputs are not reversed. When cold it does this pretty consistently. First turn of the key, tries to lock up. Second turn, starts up fine.
sixshooter-
I also own a 1926 Model T Ford. I am WELL aware of hand cranked engines and the dangers. Always put your thumb on the same side of the crank as your other fingers!
sixshooter-
I also own a 1926 Model T Ford. I am WELL aware of hand cranked engines and the dangers. Always put your thumb on the same side of the crank as your other fingers!
#45
As mentioned, I also thought there was no way a few cranks at 15ms PWs could flood the cylinders to the point where true hydro-locking occurs. I used that term loosely to describe the noise that occurs but Im glad it's not just me that suffers the problem of second attempt cold starts.
I'm playing every morning now before work to try and remedy the issue. Out of interest, can "kicking back" cause any adverse effect to the life of the engine or accessories such as the starter motor? After reading a few articles online, it seems it can.
I'll keep cringing until I can hope to tune it out.
I'm playing every morning now before work to try and remedy the issue. Out of interest, can "kicking back" cause any adverse effect to the life of the engine or accessories such as the starter motor? After reading a few articles online, it seems it can.
I'll keep cringing until I can hope to tune it out.
#46
Boost Czar
iTrader: (62)
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Chantilly, VA
Posts: 79,729
Total Cats: 4,126
The only time I've ever encountered "kick back" was when I've had my spark inputs reversed or I was injecting way too much fuel. While you may not hydro-lock the car, you can certainly flood it enough where you cannot continue to start the motor as the raw fuel will not ignite.
#48
The only time I've ever encountered "kick back" was when I've had my spark inputs reversed or I was injecting way too much fuel. While you may not hydro-lock the car, you can certainly flood it enough where you cannot continue to start the motor as the raw fuel will not ignite.
#52
Boost Czar
iTrader: (62)
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Chantilly, VA
Posts: 79,729
Total Cats: 4,126
and like I suggested before, you'll feel the "kick back" thing if it's getting flooded, you can also tend to smell it and sometimes even ignite large quantities of fuel and shoot off rockets in the exhaust.
if there's not enough fuel it will crank and crank and crank and crank without anything else odd happening, it just wont catch.
if there's not enough fuel it will crank and crank and crank and crank without anything else odd happening, it just wont catch.
#54
Then explain why mine does not do this with the coil disconnected? I can crank, and then crank some more and it will turn over fine. And it doesn't flood while playing around with no spark. Plug the coils back in and it starts right up.
Plus why will it do this on the first turn of the key, then start right up on the second? You would think that would make a flooding situation worst.
Plus why will it do this on the first turn of the key, then start right up on the second? You would think that would make a flooding situation worst.
#56
After how many seconds of cranking? How much fuel does it take to get a spark plug wet?
If the injector pulse width is too small and you crank for a few seconds, won't the cylinder eventually get enough fuel to start?
I've had lower pulse widths and many seconds of cranking and a huge fireball/missile comes out the back. Is there a science to knowing the amount of fuel the engine needs to start up? CC's or PW based on injector size.
and like I suggested before, you'll feel the "kick back" thing if it's getting flooded, you can also tend to smell it and sometimes even ignite large quantities of fuel and shoot off rockets in the exhaust.
if there's not enough fuel it will crank and crank and crank and crank without anything else odd happening, it just wont catch.
if there's not enough fuel it will crank and crank and crank and crank without anything else odd happening, it just wont catch.
I've had lower pulse widths and many seconds of cranking and a huge fireball/missile comes out the back. Is there a science to knowing the amount of fuel the engine needs to start up? CC's or PW based on injector size.
#57
It turned over fine. I got a little pop out of the intake but of course did not start. It had also done that from time to time, so I'm not sure what to make of this. (The pop, not the no start, and yes I know why)
But I have to ask, if there is no fuel for the ignition to ignite, what difference does it make where the timing is? It could be silly advanced and with no fuel it can't kick back because there is nothing to ignite? We still don't know the answer to what is causing this. I'm voting for arbitrary too far advanced timing on that first turn of the key.
I'm tempted to go back to the LoRes code. I didn't have this problem then.
#58
I finally got a working tune burned in, Then I tried to start ( cold) and it did the hard cranking thing.
I played with the cold idle wizard and let the car cool off for a few hours .
Outside temps are near 70 but I let the motor cool off much as I could and moved the cranking timing from 18 to 15.
It started fine but I'll need a few more cold start ups to tell if the setting helped.
If it was up to me I would want less rather than more fuel at start up so as to not wash the oil out of the upper cylinder area at start up....but not sure how to do this
I played with the cold idle wizard and let the car cool off for a few hours .
Outside temps are near 70 but I let the motor cool off much as I could and moved the cranking timing from 18 to 15.
It started fine but I'll need a few more cold start ups to tell if the setting helped.
If it was up to me I would want less rather than more fuel at start up so as to not wash the oil out of the upper cylinder area at start up....but not sure how to do this
Last edited by poobs; 01-14-2010 at 05:23 PM.