Work involved in a bottom end build
#1
Supporting Vendor
Thread Starter
iTrader: (10)
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Bainbridge Island, WA
Posts: 1,461
Total Cats: 388
Work involved in a bottom end build
Hey folks,
Funny how quickly things spiral out of control. I've got trubo on the way, and I need to do clutch+flywheel and a timing belt for good measure. Then I thought, hey, why not do a budget bottom end build for good measure? Thinking basically just a pistons and rods build, which I figure should cost about $1k.
So, Given that I've got to get all up in there anyway to do the timing belt and clutch, how much more work is it to pull the engine and do the aforementioned build? Am I missing anything that I'll need?
Supertech Pistons w/Rings (probably 8.5:1)
Eagle H-Beam Forged Rods
ACL Bearing Package Rod/Main/Thrust
ARP Head Studs
Thanks!
Funny how quickly things spiral out of control. I've got trubo on the way, and I need to do clutch+flywheel and a timing belt for good measure. Then I thought, hey, why not do a budget bottom end build for good measure? Thinking basically just a pistons and rods build, which I figure should cost about $1k.
So, Given that I've got to get all up in there anyway to do the timing belt and clutch, how much more work is it to pull the engine and do the aforementioned build? Am I missing anything that I'll need?
Supertech Pistons w/Rings (probably 8.5:1)
Eagle H-Beam Forged Rods
ACL Bearing Package Rod/Main/Thrust
ARP Head Studs
Thanks!
__________________
#2
Supporting Vendor
Thread Starter
iTrader: (10)
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Bainbridge Island, WA
Posts: 1,461
Total Cats: 388
Some other details that might be helpful.
My goal is for rock solid reliable daily driver power. Car is 95% street, so torque and reliability are king. If I can turn up the boost to get to 250whp, that would be sweet. And I'd take more if I could without breaking anything.
My build in progress (nb2): mkturbo, ms3x, koyo 37mm rad, gt500 injectors, fm happy meal
My goal is for rock solid reliable daily driver power. Car is 95% street, so torque and reliability are king. If I can turn up the boost to get to 250whp, that would be sweet. And I'd take more if I could without breaking anything.
My build in progress (nb2): mkturbo, ms3x, koyo 37mm rad, gt500 injectors, fm happy meal
__________________
#3
Cpt. Slow
iTrader: (25)
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Oregon City, OR
Posts: 14,360
Total Cats: 1,184
Are Eagle rods one of the expensive brands? Manelys are great, and are only $359. Something to consider.
If you have a '01+, ACL doesn't make a thrust bearing for you, so you'll have to buy an OEM mazda piece. $33 last I checked from Rosenthal Mazda.
Once it's out, you'll want to mount it on a stand. Take everything apart, labeling them nicely in baggies for later identification. ~6 engine builds later this is a much faster process, as a lot of the bolts can be easily ID'd by some obvious hardware. I.E., the baggie with the 2 ~6" m6x1 bolts is going to be for the oil pan.
Speaking of which, once it's apart, have the pan and baffle cleaned at a machine shop, and the block honed. I've cleaned the pan myself a few times, and it's a pain. I think I pay around $100 for all of this. Once done, mount the block back on the stand, paint it, and assemble your pistons/rods/rings/pins/clips. Install the crank, oil pump, and rms bracket. Install the pistons/rods with a assembly tool, bolt on the baffle/pan, and you've got a long block.
It's all the tiny details between these big steps that matter. Remembering the oil pump o-ring, setting the ring gap, cleaning surfaces well enough for the RTV to seal, etc.
If you have a '01+, ACL doesn't make a thrust bearing for you, so you'll have to buy an OEM mazda piece. $33 last I checked from Rosenthal Mazda.
Once it's out, you'll want to mount it on a stand. Take everything apart, labeling them nicely in baggies for later identification. ~6 engine builds later this is a much faster process, as a lot of the bolts can be easily ID'd by some obvious hardware. I.E., the baggie with the 2 ~6" m6x1 bolts is going to be for the oil pan.
Speaking of which, once it's apart, have the pan and baffle cleaned at a machine shop, and the block honed. I've cleaned the pan myself a few times, and it's a pain. I think I pay around $100 for all of this. Once done, mount the block back on the stand, paint it, and assemble your pistons/rods/rings/pins/clips. Install the crank, oil pump, and rms bracket. Install the pistons/rods with a assembly tool, bolt on the baffle/pan, and you've got a long block.
It's all the tiny details between these big steps that matter. Remembering the oil pump o-ring, setting the ring gap, cleaning surfaces well enough for the RTV to seal, etc.
#4
Slowest Progress Ever
iTrader: (26)
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: The coal ridden hills of Pennsylvania
Posts: 6,028
Total Cats: 304
Don't mean to thread jack, but Curly...are you suggesting using brand new stock sized rings? Then once ring gap is measured, you will file them appropriately?
#6
Supporting Vendor
Thread Starter
iTrader: (10)
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Bainbridge Island, WA
Posts: 1,461
Total Cats: 388
Thanks for the tips Curly!
Eagle and Manelys are listed as being the same price:
Are Manelys better?
What would you say, as a super rough estimate, in terms of time I should set aside for this job? And what portion of that would be saved if I'm doing the clutch, timing belt, and removing the exhaust manifold to slap on a turbo anyway?
Are Manelys better?
What would you say, as a super rough estimate, in terms of time I should set aside for this job? And what portion of that would be saved if I'm doing the clutch, timing belt, and removing the exhaust manifold to slap on a turbo anyway?
__________________
#7
Cpt. Slow
iTrader: (25)
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Oregon City, OR
Posts: 14,360
Total Cats: 1,184
Really, a timing belt/water pump job and removing the exhaust are about an hour max, of a 12-16 hour assembly job. That's taking your time and doing things properly, it's not a job you want to rush.
Disassembly depends on how orgainize you are/want to be, and takes anywhere from 1-3 hours.
I'm not sure about the manely vs. eagle question, although 949 and TSE sell manely, so they're both easily available and apparently trustworthy.
Disassembly depends on how orgainize you are/want to be, and takes anywhere from 1-3 hours.
I'm not sure about the manely vs. eagle question, although 949 and TSE sell manely, so they're both easily available and apparently trustworthy.
#8
Former Vendor
iTrader: (31)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Sunnyvale, CA
Posts: 15,442
Total Cats: 2,103
Motor assembly is a long list of tiny, important jobs. Screw one of them up and you get to start over, usually with some new parts. About 50% of the work is taking the measurements to ensure that the bores are sized correctly and round, making sure the p/w clearances and oil clearances are what they are supposed to be, setting the ring gaps, etc. 20% is cleaning the parts and assembling the rotating assembly. 30% is building from a shortblock to a longblock (head, timing gear, accessories).
Pistons and rods for $1k is a pipe dream. The rods are $350, the pistons are $450 with rings, and you still need to buy bearings ($120), an oil pump ($250-430), a full gasket kit (~$150 for everything), and pay for block machine work ($250 bare minimum). If you use stock pistons, you might be able to squeak in under $1k, but it would be very tight. By the time we add a Boundary oil pump and ARP main studs to our standard fully forged shortblocks, we're at $2600 including the cost of proper measurement and assembly.
Pistons and rods for $1k is a pipe dream. The rods are $350, the pistons are $450 with rings, and you still need to buy bearings ($120), an oil pump ($250-430), a full gasket kit (~$150 for everything), and pay for block machine work ($250 bare minimum). If you use stock pistons, you might be able to squeak in under $1k, but it would be very tight. By the time we add a Boundary oil pump and ARP main studs to our standard fully forged shortblocks, we're at $2600 including the cost of proper measurement and assembly.
#10
mkturbo.com
iTrader: (24)
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Charleston SC
Posts: 15,189
Total Cats: 1,685
Motor assembly is a long list of tiny, important jobs. Screw one of them up and you get to start over, usually with some new parts. About 50% of the work is taking the measurements to ensure that the bores are sized correctly and round, making sure the p/w clearances and oil clearances are what they are supposed to be, setting the ring gaps, etc. 20% is cleaning the parts and assembling the rotating assembly. 30% is building from a shortblock to a longblock (head, timing gear, accessories).
Pistons and rods for $1k is a pipe dream. The rods are $350, the pistons are $450 with rings, and you still need to buy bearings ($120), an oil pump ($250-430), a full gasket kit (~$150 for everything), and pay for block machine work ($250 bare minimum). If you use stock pistons, you might be able to squeak in under $1k, but it would be very tight. By the time we add a Boundary oil pump and ARP main studs to our standard fully forged shortblocks, we're at $2600 including the cost of proper measurement and assembly.
Pistons and rods for $1k is a pipe dream. The rods are $350, the pistons are $450 with rings, and you still need to buy bearings ($120), an oil pump ($250-430), a full gasket kit (~$150 for everything), and pay for block machine work ($250 bare minimum). If you use stock pistons, you might be able to squeak in under $1k, but it would be very tight. By the time we add a Boundary oil pump and ARP main studs to our standard fully forged shortblocks, we're at $2600 including the cost of proper measurement and assembly.
#12
Some other details that might be helpful.
My goal is for rock solid reliable daily driver power. Car is 95% street, so torque and reliability are king. If I can turn up the boost to get to 250whp, that would be sweet. And I'd take more if I could without breaking anything.
My build in progress (nb2): mkturbo, ms3x, koyo 37mm rad, gt500 injectors, fm happy meal
My goal is for rock solid reliable daily driver power. Car is 95% street, so torque and reliability are king. If I can turn up the boost to get to 250whp, that would be sweet. And I'd take more if I could without breaking anything.
My build in progress (nb2): mkturbo, ms3x, koyo 37mm rad, gt500 injectors, fm happy meal
#15
Former Vendor
iTrader: (31)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Sunnyvale, CA
Posts: 15,442
Total Cats: 2,103
Arguably the most critical part of building an engine, unfortunately. You can Plastigauge the oil clearances to make sure they are big enough. Your machine shop will measure the p/w clearance while boring (or they should...) and if you don't have the tools to check it, you can skip that step if you're feeling lucky. Nobody is going to clean the bores for you, though, and if you don't do it correctly, the motor won't seal up properly.
#16
Good advice in here.
OP,
I'd echo what the guys are saying and add: doing all this yourself is only cool if you 1) have the tools 2) have the time (LOTS of it for a 1st timer) 3)really want to learn and 4) willing to take the risk of failure
the more I weigh out these builds for newbies, the more I'm tempted to tell everyone to just order from TSE, 949, or even CSTG ( ).
OP,
I'd echo what the guys are saying and add: doing all this yourself is only cool if you 1) have the tools 2) have the time (LOTS of it for a 1st timer) 3)really want to learn and 4) willing to take the risk of failure
the more I weigh out these builds for newbies, the more I'm tempted to tell everyone to just order from TSE, 949, or even CSTG ( ).
#17
Elite Member
iTrader: (15)
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Murfreesboro,TN
Posts: 2,068
Total Cats: 277
Yeah, what Savington isn't mention is the cost of the tools to do all the proper measuring. I am lucky that a friend of mine has them available and was able to check everything out for me.
#18
mkturbo.com
iTrader: (24)
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Charleston SC
Posts: 15,189
Total Cats: 1,685
Good advice in here.
OP,
I'd echo what the guys are saying and add: doing all this yourself is only cool if you 1) have the tools 2) have the time (LOTS of it for a 1st timer) 3)really want to learn and 4) willing to take the risk of failure
the more I weigh out these builds for newbies, the more I'm tempted to tell everyone to just order from TSE, 949, or even CSTG ( ).
OP,
I'd echo what the guys are saying and add: doing all this yourself is only cool if you 1) have the tools 2) have the time (LOTS of it for a 1st timer) 3)really want to learn and 4) willing to take the risk of failure
the more I weigh out these builds for newbies, the more I'm tempted to tell everyone to just order from TSE, 949, or even CSTG ( ).
#19
SADFab Destructive Testing Engineer
iTrader: (5)
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: Beaverton, USA
Posts: 18,642
Total Cats: 1,866
Agree with that, unless you want to learn. Lars, if you had always just sent a check to Artech when you wanted a manifold, would we have MKTurbo? A lot of people come here to ask where to send a check, but other (me included) want to do everything they can themselves, for fun. I know that I will build my own motor, and maybe it blows up, maybe it doesn't. But for me the learning process and new skills are worth it more than anything.
#20
mkturbo.com
iTrader: (24)
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Charleston SC
Posts: 15,189
Total Cats: 1,685
Agree with that, unless you want to learn. Lars, if you had always just sent a check to Artech when you wanted a manifold, would we have MKTurbo? A lot of people come here to ask where to send a check, but other (me included) want to do everything they can themselves, for fun. I know that I will build my own motor, and maybe it blows up, maybe it doesn't. But for me the learning process and new skills are worth it more than anything.
The reason why I say writing the check is because it causes a ton less headaches. I first started down the built motor road in 2010, doing most of the work myself. 5 years later and I have had far more down time then I would have ever liked. Motor has been in and out of the car multiple times for various different engine problems. Sending a check to 949 or TSE would have cost more, but it would have been done once, correctly, and I would have been driving more and actually enjoying it. You can go check my build thread and see all the **** that has gone wrong and I have had to deal with.