Dead Engine Autopsy (picture intensive)
#1
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (12)
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Charlotte, NC
Posts: 6,850
Total Cats: 71
Dead Engine Autopsy (picture intensive)
So I finally got around to taking the head and oil pan/MBSC off the engine that died. I was hoping for a definitive cause of death....but, I'll let the pictures do the explaining. Also, on the head where I suspected the fatal compression loss to have occurred, I turned the cams and watched the valves seat across the board just fine. No signs of any valves sitting even 1mm out of place...nothing. Couldn't find any cracks in any piston, headgasket was fine.... I guess when everyhting comes apart (valves, springs, cams, rods, pistons) there may be something more obvious.
I did find a few interesting things though...but none of which I believe was a specific cause...I'll let you guys find them in the pictures.
Remember I am running a coolant re-route on the stock 01+ headgasket.
Discuss-
Valves Cylinder 1
Valves Cylinder 1
Valves Cylinder 2
Valves Cylinder 2
Valves Cylinder 4
Valves Cylinder 3
Valves Cylinder 2
Valves Cylinder 1
Engine Bottom
Cylinder 4 Rod
Cylinder 3 Rod
Cylinder 2 Rod
Cylinder 1 rod
Piston 4 w/flash
Piston 3 w/flash
Piston 2 w/flash
Piston 1 w/flash
Piston 1 closeup
Piston 2 closeup
Piston 3 closeup
Piston 4 closeup
Top of engine
I did find a few interesting things though...but none of which I believe was a specific cause...I'll let you guys find them in the pictures.
Remember I am running a coolant re-route on the stock 01+ headgasket.
Discuss-
Valves Cylinder 1
Valves Cylinder 1
Valves Cylinder 2
Valves Cylinder 2
Valves Cylinder 4
Valves Cylinder 3
Valves Cylinder 2
Valves Cylinder 1
Engine Bottom
Cylinder 4 Rod
Cylinder 3 Rod
Cylinder 2 Rod
Cylinder 1 rod
Piston 4 w/flash
Piston 3 w/flash
Piston 2 w/flash
Piston 1 w/flash
Piston 1 closeup
Piston 2 closeup
Piston 3 closeup
Piston 4 closeup
Top of engine
#6
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (12)
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Charlotte, NC
Posts: 6,850
Total Cats: 71
Things I'm thinking-
1) Detonation- I have a strong feeling the spots on valves 1 & 2 are a direct issue with the coolant reroute and the lack of flow to 1 & 2 because of the headgasket design. A track day the week before brought on some ignition-like problems. I have a feeling the cylinder head was getting VERY hot on 1 & 2. Odd how there is detonation on PISTON 4, but not on VALVE 4, PISTON 1 looks decent/no metallic dust from detonation like #4.
Carbon buildup-
I had been on the track for a few sessions a week before and had some ignition issues that produced a metric TON of unburnt fuel. I didn't drive the car much after that track day and didn't "blow it out". Also, I tried a TON of times to fire the engine back up and there were several MINUTES where it ran stupid rich because the engine was barely turning over...massive amounts of unburned fuel fumes filled my garage...plugs fouled. Oh and when the engine died (while moving and in gear) I opened the throttle multiple times to see if it would return to normal...lots of flames came out the exhaust doing so...more unburned fuel.
Bent rod- Dunno. Considering the detonation on the top of #4, I'd think that would be the logical one to be bent. Only thing that makes sense to me is excessive heat and detonation from the coolant reroute.
What do you guys think of what I think?
1) Detonation- I have a strong feeling the spots on valves 1 & 2 are a direct issue with the coolant reroute and the lack of flow to 1 & 2 because of the headgasket design. A track day the week before brought on some ignition-like problems. I have a feeling the cylinder head was getting VERY hot on 1 & 2. Odd how there is detonation on PISTON 4, but not on VALVE 4, PISTON 1 looks decent/no metallic dust from detonation like #4.
Carbon buildup-
I had been on the track for a few sessions a week before and had some ignition issues that produced a metric TON of unburnt fuel. I didn't drive the car much after that track day and didn't "blow it out". Also, I tried a TON of times to fire the engine back up and there were several MINUTES where it ran stupid rich because the engine was barely turning over...massive amounts of unburned fuel fumes filled my garage...plugs fouled. Oh and when the engine died (while moving and in gear) I opened the throttle multiple times to see if it would return to normal...lots of flames came out the exhaust doing so...more unburned fuel.
Bent rod- Dunno. Considering the detonation on the top of #4, I'd think that would be the logical one to be bent. Only thing that makes sense to me is excessive heat and detonation from the coolant reroute.
What do you guys think of what I think?
#12
Senior Member
iTrader: (14)
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: South East Florida
Posts: 677
Total Cats: 6
Is it the pictures of the valves that is giving away the detonation? I have been staring at the pictures of the pistons for five minutes and can not see a noticeable difference between them..
#16
Like everyone has already said, I agree with detonation in 1 and 2. And #1 rod does look bent in the pic.
__________________
Best Car Insurance | Auto Protection Today | FREE Trade-In Quote
__________________
Best Car Insurance | Auto Protection Today | FREE Trade-In Quote
#17
1 & 2 will be ugly, and were probably a week from losing material on the crown by the time you started losing compression.
#1 rod definitely bent, and I imagine another one is bent on the other axis. Mine were split dead even like that...one on each axis, and one on both axes, last one fine.
I've seen worse carbon on valves, but the head and pistons have a LOT. Detonation probably worked the surface a little giving it more of a foothold, although the build-up may have been there long before, contributing to the det. I forget how many of your miles were boosted...