Stock ECU fuel management
#2
Your fuel / ignition concerns will be that the stock ECU is woefully incapable of compensating for boost.
While you can absolutely pile on several bandaids to prevent it from blowing up, by the time you've actually managed to build a halfway drivable car that doesn't buck when you transition into boost or blow smoke every time you shift you could have just bought yourself a standalone ECU for the same price (or less...).
While you can absolutely pile on several bandaids to prevent it from blowing up, by the time you've actually managed to build a halfway drivable car that doesn't buck when you transition into boost or blow smoke every time you shift you could have just bought yourself a standalone ECU for the same price (or less...).
#3
Boost Pope
iTrader: (8)
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 33,556
Total Cats: 6,933
From: Chicago. (The less-murder part.)
Phil, where do you live, and what are the emission-testing requirements, if any?
The most cost-effective solution depends largely on your answer to the above, as well as to how comfortable you are with electronics, software, engine-tuning, etc.
At the low end of the scale, you could install a rising-rate fuel pressure regulator (such as the complete BEGI fuel system, with FPR and pump) and just throw on an adjustable crank trigger wheel so you can dial in a few degrees of static retard.
Moving up in the world, there are a number of piggyback solutions which, to some degree or another, work.
Then at the upper end of the scale you have "standalone" ECUs, which completely replace the stock ECU and can properly drive larger injectors, integrate feedback from a wideband exhaust gas sensor, etc. Megasquirt, Hydra, etc., fall in this this category.
The most cost-effective solution depends largely on your answer to the above, as well as to how comfortable you are with electronics, software, engine-tuning, etc.
At the low end of the scale, you could install a rising-rate fuel pressure regulator (such as the complete BEGI fuel system, with FPR and pump) and just throw on an adjustable crank trigger wheel so you can dial in a few degrees of static retard.
Moving up in the world, there are a number of piggyback solutions which, to some degree or another, work.
Then at the upper end of the scale you have "standalone" ECUs, which completely replace the stock ECU and can properly drive larger injectors, integrate feedback from a wideband exhaust gas sensor, etc. Megasquirt, Hydra, etc., fall in this this category.
#4
Phil, where do you live, and what are the emission-testing requirements, if any?
The most cost-effective solution depends largely on your answer to the above, as well as to how comfortable you are with electronics, software, engine-tuning, etc.
At the low end of the scale, you could install a rising-rate fuel pressure regulator (such as the complete BEGI fuel system, with FPR and pump) and just throw on an adjustable crank trigger wheel so you can dial in a few degrees of static retard.
Moving up in the world, there are a number of piggyback solutions which, to some degree or another, work.
Then at the upper end of the scale you have "standalone" ECUs, which completely replace the stock ECU and can properly drive larger injectors, integrate feedback from a wideband exhaust gas sensor, etc. Megasquirt, Hydra, etc., fall in this this category.
The most cost-effective solution depends largely on your answer to the above, as well as to how comfortable you are with electronics, software, engine-tuning, etc.
At the low end of the scale, you could install a rising-rate fuel pressure regulator (such as the complete BEGI fuel system, with FPR and pump) and just throw on an adjustable crank trigger wheel so you can dial in a few degrees of static retard.
Moving up in the world, there are a number of piggyback solutions which, to some degree or another, work.
Then at the upper end of the scale you have "standalone" ECUs, which completely replace the stock ECU and can properly drive larger injectors, integrate feedback from a wideband exhaust gas sensor, etc. Megasquirt, Hydra, etc., fall in this this category.
How about the FM Voodoo box w/ crank trigger wheel?
#12
Boost Pope
iTrader: (8)
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 33,556
Total Cats: 6,933
From: Chicago. (The less-murder part.)
It does work, you just have to place the aux pump up front under the hood, and create a recirculating loop, in which the RRFPR's dump line feeds back into the aux pump inlet.
Ah, yeah. I forgot about you late-model guys with your wiggly camshafts.
#13
EDIT: Given that. I have learned a lot over the past 6 months with the unit and how to tune with not a lot of prior knowledge.
And I went with the larger BPV because I'm running a much larger turbo and the forge wasn't cutting it. Plus I'm running 15-16psi. And the motor is coming out thursday for new rods and I'm going to be bumping it up to 20-23ish psi afterwards.
Last edited by slmhofy; 12-11-2012 at 01:43 AM.
#14
'04 Miata to MSM turbo conversion
Since I am adding the MSM Miata turbo to my N/A '04 Miata, I have only (1) IAT sensor available to insert into the intake piping (I think the stock MSM turbo setup has (2) IAT sensors). Should the (1) IAT sensor in my setup go right after the MAF on the coldside (before turbo) or in the TB inlet pipe (charge pipe)? Shouldn't the MAF always be before the turbo on the coldside inlet pipe?
#16
I would go with an MS if I were you and a reverant built one sounds like your best option. That is what I run in my MSM and I had no experience with soldering, wiring, or tuning before I bought my MS2 from rev. He sets them up so well that if you can't install it in a weekend then you shouldn't be working on cars.
My car runs well and I picked up a **** ton of midrange over the stock MSM ecu.
My car runs well and I picked up a **** ton of midrange over the stock MSM ecu.
#19
Its a little more than I want to take on either. I had a complete engine/turbo/intercooler from an 04 MSM lined up so I could do a legal turbo swap in my 00, but the dude sold it out from under me. Unless another one falls in my lap, I'll be sitting on this stuff for a while.
I've got a DIYPNP in my 00 and I wish I'd held out for one of Reverants enhanced MS2 units. He builds a great product and consistently gets positive comments. They are more expensive, but the extra features are pretty bauce.
I've got a DIYPNP in my 00 and I wish I'd held out for one of Reverants enhanced MS2 units. He builds a great product and consistently gets positive comments. They are more expensive, but the extra features are pretty bauce.