Operativity window on NB camshaft sensor
#1
Operativity window on NB camshaft sensor
Hi folks
we're having some trouble related to a miata BP (non-vvt version) and need deeper understanding of ignition timing. AFAIK the ecu use the 1+2 pins on intake camshaft just for undestand if the engine is on a "even" stroke or "odd" stroke (i really could expain better).
The customer asked us to adapt a NA adjustable camshaft pulley with pins in order to get camshaft position signal (1+2 pins). We've alterady done it in the past with good results, however always with programmable ecus.
The issue is that as per pulley design, changing the timing with the pulley slider will result in changing the timing of the 1+2 pins. So che camshaft sensor could sense the pins +/- 16° crank degrees (the pulley on canshaft count for +/- 8° cam degrees).
Does anybody knows how large is the "window" for the original ecu to see the 1+2 pins? Will it pop CEL up because the pins is NOT when it is needed to be or it simply expect 1 or 2 pin in the whole 180 cam arc?
TL;DR : or has anybody make working the original NB timing 4 belt theeth off? if no error related to ignition/cam/crank showed up, the ecu did not check "where" the pins are related to crank, and they passing by is just enought.
we're having some trouble related to a miata BP (non-vvt version) and need deeper understanding of ignition timing. AFAIK the ecu use the 1+2 pins on intake camshaft just for undestand if the engine is on a "even" stroke or "odd" stroke (i really could expain better).
The customer asked us to adapt a NA adjustable camshaft pulley with pins in order to get camshaft position signal (1+2 pins). We've alterady done it in the past with good results, however always with programmable ecus.
The issue is that as per pulley design, changing the timing with the pulley slider will result in changing the timing of the 1+2 pins. So che camshaft sensor could sense the pins +/- 16° crank degrees (the pulley on canshaft count for +/- 8° cam degrees).
Does anybody knows how large is the "window" for the original ecu to see the 1+2 pins? Will it pop CEL up because the pins is NOT when it is needed to be or it simply expect 1 or 2 pin in the whole 180 cam arc?
TL;DR : or has anybody make working the original NB timing 4 belt theeth off? if no error related to ignition/cam/crank showed up, the ecu did not check "where" the pins are related to crank, and they passing by is just enought.
#3
Maybe i explained not so well
I am talking about the 1+2 theeth of the CAM sensor
The car would still mechanically timed correctly, but as per the adjustable cam pulley is made, the theeth would happen to pass the sensor up to 8 degrees out of timing. Did anyone know of wide is the ECU window to see those theeth pass by before putting on a CEL or having issue?
On programmable ecu's like ME442 we tested it in the past: the ecu just want to see the theeth in the whole 180° arc, that's enought. But i really dont know about stock NB ecu
I am talking about the 1+2 theeth of the CAM sensor
The car would still mechanically timed correctly, but as per the adjustable cam pulley is made, the theeth would happen to pass the sensor up to 8 degrees out of timing. Did anyone know of wide is the ECU window to see those theeth pass by before putting on a CEL or having issue?
On programmable ecu's like ME442 we tested it in the past: the ecu just want to see the theeth in the whole 180° arc, that's enought. But i really dont know about stock NB ecu
#4
Adjustable bracket
4 teeth is way off BTW
4 teeth is way off BTW
which i think is operatively the same thing as our adjustable trigger wheel ?
#6
not really
maruha cam gear style has the notches on the belt side of pulley, so they stay in timing with the crank no matter how you adjust it
we have per customer request to modify a cam pulley for NA miata, and it has not the space for the notches. so they have to being placed on the cam side of the slider, so they account for the adjusting, and be adjusted w/ the cam (so out of timing in respect of the belt).
maruha cam gear style has the notches on the belt side of pulley, so they stay in timing with the crank no matter how you adjust it
we have per customer request to modify a cam pulley for NA miata, and it has not the space for the notches. so they have to being placed on the cam side of the slider, so they account for the adjusting, and be adjusted w/ the cam (so out of timing in respect of the belt).
#7
I am a bit confused, you have an NA8 or a BP? The NA8 uses the CAS, BP uses the cam/crank sensors. Are you wanting to put an NA8 adjustable pulley on a BP with a CAM sensor?
Edit: OK, just googled, I think I do understand now. Might be a silly question, but why not just get the Maruha pulley?
I do see that on some vendors sites they mention adding the timing nubs to the pulley, maybe contact them directly to see if they have any thoughts?
You could always test with a stock BP pulley and intentionally time it 1 tooth out to see if the ECU throws a code. I personally don't have much (any) experience with the stock ECUs. It is interesting that the Maruha cam elected to place the timing marks on the belt side of the pulley, this might be a clue.
Edit: OK, just googled, I think I do understand now. Might be a silly question, but why not just get the Maruha pulley?
I do see that on some vendors sites they mention adding the timing nubs to the pulley, maybe contact them directly to see if they have any thoughts?
You could always test with a stock BP pulley and intentionally time it 1 tooth out to see if the ECU throws a code. I personally don't have much (any) experience with the stock ECUs. It is interesting that the Maruha cam elected to place the timing marks on the belt side of the pulley, this might be a clue.
Last edited by Ted75zcar; 09-11-2023 at 12:56 PM.
#9
It only needs one pin. You can see its welded to a flat washer to place it on the scribe mark you made that represents the single node on the stock gear. This way you have a reference scribe mark if you need it . You will also need a spacer for the sensor. Gap for the node to the sensor I found needed less than business card. I also tried to match the shape of the node but that may not be necessary. I did this about five years ago on an AEM Infinity. The ecu may or may not matter.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post