ACL vs OEM vs Enginetech Bearings
#1
ACL vs OEM vs Enginetech Bearings
Hey all, I am in the process of rebuilding my engine, compression is super low and it hesitates/misfires in the morning. My original plan was to just restore it to factory spec but my tax return allows me to get the forged rotating assembly out of the way now so I don't have to pull the motor apart again when I turbo in a year or two.
This is what I'm throwing in:
Wiseco 83.5mm 10.5:1 Pistons and NPR XX Rings
Manley H-Beam Rods
I was going to get everything else from Rock Auto, which means Engine Tech bearings and Fel-Pro gaskets (the head gasket is MLS). Would it be worth the extra money to get the ACL bearings? I plan on buying a refurbished head and doing the valve springs/retainers/seats when it actually comes time, no need to spend on that if I'm not going turbo at the second. Also considering doing the Boundary oil pump right now since you have to pull the motor to do that too.
This is what I'm throwing in:
Wiseco 83.5mm 10.5:1 Pistons and NPR XX Rings
Manley H-Beam Rods
I was going to get everything else from Rock Auto, which means Engine Tech bearings and Fel-Pro gaskets (the head gasket is MLS). Would it be worth the extra money to get the ACL bearings? I plan on buying a refurbished head and doing the valve springs/retainers/seats when it actually comes time, no need to spend on that if I'm not going turbo at the second. Also considering doing the Boundary oil pump right now since you have to pull the motor to do that too.
#2
Elite Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: Jacksonville, FL
Posts: 1,552
Total Cats: 196
Are you planning on a 400hp e85 turbo build in the future?
10.5cr pistons are not turbo friendly, unless going e85.
You want 8.6 pistons for turbo pump gas
You also want all oem seals and head gasket. Doing seals again once the engine is in, is no fun.
10.5cr pistons are not turbo friendly, unless going e85.
You want 8.6 pistons for turbo pump gas
You also want all oem seals and head gasket. Doing seals again once the engine is in, is no fun.
#3
Edit: Forgot to mention the motor will be N/A on the stock ECU for about a year while I save up for the rest of the components. I'd rather have closer to stock compression (10:1) and then just run the car on E85 when I add boost to greatly help my power goal.
Question was for the bearings though, not the seals lol. I don't mind Fel-Pro, I've used their products a lot and they do their job. It's just the bearings I'm worried about because that is a pretty critical component to any rebuild. I haven't heard anything bad about Engine Tech bearings but I'm not sure how well they will withstand 9000RPM and 400ish lb/ft of torque.
Last edited by achulz; 02-11-2019 at 06:26 PM.
#6
I understand the bearings are a critical component that I should not cheap out on, my question was more in particular to see if someone else had used them before and how they held up compared to more expensive bearings. Obviously I should go for ACL bearings based on this feedback. BUT, y'all are going way overboard about the gaskets. They are GASKETS. Literally any aftermarket engine overhaul kit is going to perform the same if not better than OEM, and for much less. There is ZERO point in searching for and purchasing all OEM gaskets and seals when aftermarket kits do the same job for much less.
I know it takes $$$ to build a BP to make that much power, but that's why I'm taking it slow and doing it one step at a time. Rotating assembly first, then accessories, transmission, etc. I don't have $10K to drop in one day, but I can do it over time. And while I'm at it, I'm going to save money on everything I can that is not critical to this motor making 500 crank hp reliably. This forum in particular need to learn something, and that's that not everyone can buy all the parts YOU think should go into the build. If it's absolutely necessary then yes, but most of the time y'all don't even have the experience to back up your claims that [part] is critical to the reliable operation of the motor. I've used all kinds of different parts brands of the years on NUMEROUS different cars, not one of them has caused me any trouble and performs as it should. It's one thing to pick on someone for using a $200 eBay turbo cast in someone's backyard but bashing someone for not using OEM gaskets when there are plenty of other reasonably priced options is just arrogant and completely stupid. Being smart with your money and saving where you can adds up big time, it's not a matter of being cheap.
I've been a mechanic my entire life, 10 years professionally. I have multiple welding certifications and tons of fabrication experience. I've rebuilt motors, automatic and manual transmissions, etc. None of this **** is new to me.
I hate to rant but every time I go on this forum the threads end up as "you didn't spend enough money so your build is worthless and is going to explode in 500 miles". Give people a chance and stop being so negative. Explain to them why it won't work. Suggest an alternative. You're only putting yourself and others down instead of growing the community and knowledge base as a whole.
#8
If you can get a "racer" account through Mazda Motorsports, the OEM parts are actually really reasonable. My only complaint is that their shipping charges are high if you are only ordering a couple things. I usually try to save up all my parts needs and spread the shipping cost out a bit. If you are building an engine, you can easily make an order big enough.
The site isn't great to use, but they do have most of the parts diagrams to help you identify part numbers on there.
The site isn't great to use, but they do have most of the parts diagrams to help you identify part numbers on there.
#9
Former Vendor
iTrader: (31)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Sunnyvale, CA
Posts: 15,442
Total Cats: 2,103
Tweak your attitude, quickly. This forum is full of people who have done exactly what you want to do. I'm one of them. Telling us how arrogant and stupid we are is going to get you absolutely nowhere.
https://www.miataturbo.net/dynos-tim...-scared-95108/
#10
Okay, let me get something straight.
I understand the bearings are a critical component that I should not cheap out on, my question was more in particular to see if someone else had used them before and how they held up compared to more expensive bearings. Obviously I should go for ACL bearings based on this feedback. BUT, y'all are going way overboard about the gaskets. They are GASKETS. Literally any aftermarket engine overhaul kit is going to perform the same if not better than OEM, and for much less. There is ZERO point in searching for and purchasing all OEM gaskets and seals when aftermarket kits do the same job for much less.
I know it takes $$$ to build a BP to make that much power, but that's why I'm taking it slow and doing it one step at a time. Rotating assembly first, then accessories, transmission, etc. I don't have $10K to drop in one day, but I can do it over time. And while I'm at it, I'm going to save money on everything I can that is not critical to this motor making 500 crank hp reliably. This forum in particular need to learn something, and that's that not everyone can buy all the parts YOU think should go into the build. If it's absolutely necessary then yes, but most of the time y'all don't even have the experience to back up your claims that [part] is critical to the reliable operation of the motor. I've used all kinds of different parts brands of the years on NUMEROUS different cars, not one of them has caused me any trouble and performs as it should. It's one thing to pick on someone for using a $200 eBay turbo cast in someone's backyard but bashing someone for not using OEM gaskets when there are plenty of other reasonably priced options is just arrogant and completely stupid. Being smart with your money and saving where you can adds up big time, it's not a matter of being cheap.
I've been a mechanic my entire life, 10 years professionally. I have multiple welding certifications and tons of fabrication experience. I've rebuilt motors, automatic and manual transmissions, etc. None of this **** is new to me.
I hate to rant but every time I go on this forum the threads end up as "you didn't spend enough money so your build is worthless and is going to explode in 500 miles". Give people a chance and stop being so negative. Explain to them why it won't work. Suggest an alternative. You're only putting yourself and others down instead of growing the community and knowledge base as a whole.
I understand the bearings are a critical component that I should not cheap out on, my question was more in particular to see if someone else had used them before and how they held up compared to more expensive bearings. Obviously I should go for ACL bearings based on this feedback. BUT, y'all are going way overboard about the gaskets. They are GASKETS. Literally any aftermarket engine overhaul kit is going to perform the same if not better than OEM, and for much less. There is ZERO point in searching for and purchasing all OEM gaskets and seals when aftermarket kits do the same job for much less.
I know it takes $$$ to build a BP to make that much power, but that's why I'm taking it slow and doing it one step at a time. Rotating assembly first, then accessories, transmission, etc. I don't have $10K to drop in one day, but I can do it over time. And while I'm at it, I'm going to save money on everything I can that is not critical to this motor making 500 crank hp reliably. This forum in particular need to learn something, and that's that not everyone can buy all the parts YOU think should go into the build. If it's absolutely necessary then yes, but most of the time y'all don't even have the experience to back up your claims that [part] is critical to the reliable operation of the motor. I've used all kinds of different parts brands of the years on NUMEROUS different cars, not one of them has caused me any trouble and performs as it should. It's one thing to pick on someone for using a $200 eBay turbo cast in someone's backyard but bashing someone for not using OEM gaskets when there are plenty of other reasonably priced options is just arrogant and completely stupid. Being smart with your money and saving where you can adds up big time, it's not a matter of being cheap.
I've been a mechanic my entire life, 10 years professionally. I have multiple welding certifications and tons of fabrication experience. I've rebuilt motors, automatic and manual transmissions, etc. None of this **** is new to me.
I hate to rant but every time I go on this forum the threads end up as "you didn't spend enough money so your build is worthless and is going to explode in 500 miles". Give people a chance and stop being so negative. Explain to them why it won't work. Suggest an alternative. You're only putting yourself and others down instead of growing the community and knowledge base as a whole.
What's your question, again?
#11
In my opinion, its better to cry once on costs up front, than twice when it has to come back apart and spend money again on seals.
Heres my take on seals and gaskets. If its a rubber seal (cam seals, mains, valve cover gasket, etc) get OEM. I've had plenty of fail-pro seals leak in a short time.
Paper gaskets, who cares really.
As far as bearings, head gasket, and "please dont fail and destroy my engine" parts, peace of mind is priceless. Gotta be able to sleep at night, lol.
Heres my take on seals and gaskets. If its a rubber seal (cam seals, mains, valve cover gasket, etc) get OEM. I've had plenty of fail-pro seals leak in a short time.
Paper gaskets, who cares really.
As far as bearings, head gasket, and "please dont fail and destroy my engine" parts, peace of mind is priceless. Gotta be able to sleep at night, lol.
#13
Former Vendor
iTrader: (31)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Sunnyvale, CA
Posts: 15,442
Total Cats: 2,103
There certainly wasn't a time period where aftermarket oil pumps were being shipped with aftermarket seals that would leak and pop out of place. No, that never happened. And, if it did happen, installing an OEM front main seal in its place never fixed the problem.
What were we talking about, again?
What were we talking about, again?
#14
This thread makes no sense. If you have so much experience and knowledge, wouldn't part of that experience and knowledge be an understanding that maybe some other people know more than you about these motors? And that some of the products they suggest are due to to those products being tested and trusted?
#15
mkturbo.com
iTrader: (24)
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Charleston SC
Posts: 15,189
Total Cats: 1,685
BUT, y'all are going way overboard about the gaskets. They are GASKETS. Literally any aftermarket engine overhaul kit is going to perform the same if not better than OEM, and for much less. There is ZERO point in searching for and purchasing all OEM gaskets and seals when aftermarket kits do the same job for much less.
This is coming from someone who regularly uses $50 timing belt and water pump kits from ebay with zero hesitation. OEM rubber seals is worth it.
#17
Moderator
iTrader: (12)
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Tampa, Florida
Posts: 20,884
Total Cats: 3,075
This is so reminiscent of the guys who think they can build an exhaust manifold for a turbo Miata the same way they are built for Nissans and Hondas and have them survive. Our farm tractor engines have terrible harmonics and those other brands don't have those issues. Those guys come here and say, "I'm going to build it like this because this worked on my Honda and you guys are idiots." And they fail.
Part of being a good mechanic is figuring out there are quirks to every brand.
Another example, Toyota generally builds very good engines, but certain models of 2.4 liter 4 cylinders have a known issue with head bolts pulling out of the aluminum block and others do not. But you wouldn't know it unless you talked to someone who already knew it.
Again, we are cheap skates and we do things the easiest way we can. Sometimes easiest means only having to do it once.
#18
Elite Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: Jacksonville, FL
Posts: 1,552
Total Cats: 196
i love when people come for advise, then start schooling us on why we are all idiots that are doing everything wrong.
adjust your attitude or go back to bookface groups.
I don't think You will find many people With 400 horsepower engine builds that run Engine tech bearings.
Most here run ACL or King Bearings.
I am no expert on bearings So I went with the flow And got myself ACL bearings, They work Fine for me
I am no mechanic, But in my Experience Anytime I used Aftermarket Crank shaft seals They all leaked.
For this reason I now only use oem seals And nothing else.
adjust your attitude or go back to bookface groups.
I don't think You will find many people With 400 horsepower engine builds that run Engine tech bearings.
Most here run ACL or King Bearings.
I am no expert on bearings So I went with the flow And got myself ACL bearings, They work Fine for me
I am no mechanic, But in my Experience Anytime I used Aftermarket Crank shaft seals They all leaked.
For this reason I now only use oem seals And nothing else.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
rappit4
Engine Performance
13
06-03-2019 09:04 AM
axertion
Engine Performance
29
08-24-2018 02:37 PM
Chooofoojoo
Engine Performance
1
01-15-2015 04:48 PM
danscreations
DIY Turbo Discussion
17
03-31-2009 10:13 PM